TL;DR
Get decor and gifts delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Apartment Therapy writer Laura Wheatman Hill tested a steamer, a Bissell upholstery cleaner and a homemade vinegar, water and dish soap solution on separate cushions of the same couch. She reported that the homemade mix worked best for removing dog odor, based on her own assessment and feedback from her son; the test was not a controlled comparison.
Apartment Therapy writer Laura Wheatman Hill tested three ways to remove dog odor from couch cushions and reported that a homemade vinegar, water and dish soap solution worked best. Her comparison covered a steamer, a Bissell Pet Stain Eraser and the homemade mixture, with feedback from Hill and her son informing the odor assessment.
Hill tested each method on a different cushion or pillow on the same sectional. She vacuumed the cushions before the tests and tried the methods back-to-back. To assess the odor before and after cleaning, she removed each cushion and asked her younger son, whom she describes as especially sensitive to smells, to give feedback. The report does not describe a laboratory test or a blinded comparison.
For the homemade cleaner, Hill mixed 1/4 cup white vinegar, 3/4 cup warm water and 1 tablespoon dish soap in a spray bottle. She sprayed a cushion, scrubbed it with a microfiber cloth, misted it with plain water and wiped it again, then left it to dry. Hill said this approach was the most effective of the three at neutralizing the dog odor, and that it required less work than the alternatives.
Hill also used a steamer and a Bissell Pet Stain Eraser with the recommended Pet Pro cleaning solution. She rated the Bissell method 3 out of 5 in the supplied report: the cushion remained damp after repeated vacuum passes, and a cleaner scent lingered the next day, though her son said the dog smell was gone. The source material does not give the steamer’s rating or a detailed account of its result.
A Low-Cost Option for Couch Odor
The report offers readers a practical cleaning option using common household ingredients rather than relying only on a dedicated upholstery machine or steamer. Hill said the mixture was both the best performer in her test and the least work, making it a potentially useful first step for people dealing with everyday dog odor on fabric cushions.
The result should be read as one household test, not proof that the recipe will work on every sofa or fabric. Couch materials, cleaning instructions and the source or severity of an odor can vary. The article’s account may help readers compare approaches, but it does not establish that the mixture is safe for all upholstery or that it removes stains, allergens or germs.
Products Worth Considering
EGO Power+ PST3041 3000W Nexus Portable Power Station with Four 5.0Ah Batteries
DeWalt DCN930P1 20V 30° Framing Nailer Kit
Milwaukee M12 FUEL 12V 1/4-Inch Hex Cordless Impact Driver Kit
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How Hill Compared the Cleaners
Hill said she wanted to freshen her couch ahead of holiday visitors because she had struggled to get what she called the “dog smell” out of its upholstery. She chose three methods available to her and applied them to different cushions on the same sectional after vacuuming. This setup let her compare the methods in her home, but each method was tested on a separate cushion rather than on identical sections under controlled conditions.
Apartment Therapy identifies the piece as a first-person cleaning report by Hill, who lives in Portland, Oregon. The publication says it independently selects products and may earn a commission if readers buy through its links; the supplied material does not specify a purchase link associated with this test. Its quick instructions for the winning recipe give the measurements and steps, but do not include guidance for every upholstery type.
““I can never get rid of the ‘dog smell’ in my soft, upholstered couch, despite my best efforts.””
— Laura Wheatman Hill, Apartment Therapy
Limits of the Couch Test
The supplied report does not include the steamer’s result or rating, so readers cannot compare its performance in detail with the other two methods from the available account. It also does not state how long the homemade solution took to dry, whether the cushions were made of the same fabric, or whether Hill checked for changes in color or texture.
The report does not establish how well the recipe works on other upholstery, older or deeply embedded odors, or stains. Hill’s assessment and her son’s feedback are personal observations, not a controlled measure of odor. Readers should check a couch’s care label and test any cleaner on an inconspicuous area before treating a larger section; the supplied material does not provide fabric-specific safety guidance.
Hill Plans Another Couch Pass
Hill said she still plans to steam the entire couch after using the vinegar-based mixture, which she described as an additional sanitizing step. The report does not specify when she will do this or whether she will publish a follow-up with results. For now, the documented finding is limited to her comparison of three methods on separate cushions in her home.
Key Questions
Which method did Hill say worked best?
Hill reported that a mix of white vinegar, warm water and dish soap was the most effective of the three methods she tested for neutralizing dog odor.
What are the recipe measurements?
The recipe calls for 1/4 cup white vinegar, 3/4 cup warm water and 1 tablespoon dish soap. Hill sprayed it onto a cushion, scrubbed with a microfiber cloth, misted with plain water, wiped again and let the cushion dry.
Did the Bissell cleaner remove the odor?
Hill said her son confirmed that the actual dog smell was gone after she used the Bissell Pet Stain Eraser. However, the cushion stayed damp longer than she wanted, and a cleaner scent remained the next day.
Was this a controlled test?
No. Hill tested each method on a different cushion or pillow on the same couch and relied on her own assessment and her son’s feedback. The report does not describe a controlled or laboratory comparison.
Will the mixture work on every couch?
The report does not establish that. Upholstery materials and care instructions differ, so readers should check the couch’s care label and test a small, inconspicuous area before applying a cleaner more broadly.
Source: apartmenttherapy.com
